Cookies on this site. Help us understand what works and improve your experience. Essential cookies keep the site working. With your permission, our visit insights and Google Analytics measure usage, and Google Ads measures advertising. Optional cookies are not required to use the free kit. Change your choice anytime in Cookie settings. Privacy policyCookie policy
Have your security approach reviewed independently at planned intervals or after major changes.
Is it mandatory? Not automatically. You must consider this control in your Statement of Applicability (6.1.3 d). Include it if your risk assessment, laws, contracts or business needs require it; if you exclude it, write down a justification an auditor will accept.
Why this control matters
Independent review is strongest when the reviewer is sufficiently detached from the activity being examined and when findings are translated into corrective action. A common weakness is treating review as a calendar event rather than a targeted challenge to recent changes, control failures, or recurring risk areas. Teams should coordinate internal audits, external tests, and management reporting so reviews examine both design and operating evidence.
Common auditor findings to check for
Potential gaps to test in your own environment, not a claim about observed audit frequency.
The audit programme exists, but it does not explain independence, scope selection, or how reviews follow major changes such as cloud migrations, incidents, or supplier transitions.
Review results are reported verbally or in a slide deck, but findings lack clear owners, due dates, or status tracking, so corrective action cannot be verified later.
Technical reviews occur, yet evidence is not retained in a way that shows what was tested, which systems were in scope, and whether exceptions were accepted or remediated.
How you can implement it
Tools and review intervals are examples; choose them according to risk, obligations and your operating environment.
Build an annual audit programme from risk, change, and previous findings. The audit owner should select topics based on critical controls, major process changes, and unresolved issues, then assign auditors who are independent of the area under review and competent for the technique being used.
For each review, define scope, criteria, sampling approach, and evidence sources before fieldwork starts. Where a technical test is used, note whether it is a configuration check, interview, document review, or vulnerability assessment, and ensure results are traceable to specific systems or control statements.
Record findings in a register that links each issue to corrective action, responsible owner, target date, and closure evidence. Use management review to challenge overdue items, recurring nonconformities, and systemic causes, not just to acknowledge that an audit took place.
After major incidents, platform changes, or supplier transitions, schedule an ad hoc independent review. This may examine access changes, logging gaps, backup restoration, or policy exceptions. The purpose is to test whether the changed environment still matches the intended security design and risk treatment assumptions.
What an auditor will ask to see
Approved audit programme showing scope, timing, independence, and review topics.
Completed audit reports with criteria, samples, observations, and assigned action items.
Use the SIG and CAIQ questionnaire accelerator to find supporting documents. A mapping is a starting point: verify your actual operating evidence before answering a buyer.
For help adapting this to your environment, explore ISO/IEC 27001 consulting, starting with a free one-hour consultation.
Get these documents tailored to your organization
109 ready-to-edit documents, including all 19 mandatory ones, tailored from a short scoping questionnaire and linked to your risk register and SoA.