Clause 9 – Performance evaluation

Clause 9.3 Management review

Mandatory requirement Documented information required

What it means in plain language

Top management must review the ISMS at planned intervals (at least yearly) using defined inputs – status of past actions, changes, performance, audit results, risks, opportunities – and decide on improvements and changes.

Is it mandatory? Yes. Clauses 4–10 are the management-system requirements; all of them must be met to be certified, and none can be excluded.

Documented information

  • Results of management reviews.

Why this requirement matters

The operational priority is management review as a decision-making checkpoint, not a ceremonial meeting. Top management needs a repeatable agenda that brings together performance data, audit results, risks, incidents, supplier issues, resource needs, and progress on earlier actions, so the ISMS can be adjusted where needed and improvement decisions are recorded with clear accountability.

Common auditor findings to check for

Potential gaps to test in your own environment, not a claim about observed audit frequency.

  • The review is held, but required inputs are incomplete, so management cannot see whether the ISMS remains suitable, adequate, and effective across all relevant areas.
  • Minutes capture discussion yet do not record decisions, owners, or deadlines, making it hard to prove that management acted on the information presented.
  • Review actions are reopened or missed because follow-up is informal and no one reconciles outstanding items against the prior minutes before the next meeting.

How you can implement it

Tools and review intervals are examples; choose them according to risk, obligations and your operating environment.

  • Use the Management Review Procedure to define a fixed cadence, usually yearly and more often where major incidents, acquisitions, or regulatory changes occur. Keep a standing agenda that covers prior actions, changes in context, audit results, monitoring trends, incidents, risk treatment status, supplier performance, resource sufficiency, and opportunities for improvement.
  • Prepare a concise management pack before the meeting, drawing from KPI dashboards, the nonconformity register, risk assessment outputs, internal audit results, incident summaries, training status, and open improvement items. Assign a coordinator to check completeness and chase missing inputs several days before the meeting.
  • Record decisions in the Management Review Minutes as explicit actions, not general discussion. Each action should identify an owner, target date, and desired outcome, such as revising an objective, approving resources, changing scope, or accepting a risk treatment delay with justification.
  • At the next review, close the loop by reporting which actions were completed, late, deferred, or cancelled, and why. Escalate overdue items to senior leadership between meetings if they affect risk posture, compliance obligations, supplier control, or operational continuity.

What an auditor will ask to see

  • Management review agenda and pre-read pack showing all required input categories.
  • Signed minutes with decisions, action owners, due dates, and status of prior actions.
  • Management-approved changes to objectives, resources, scope, or risk treatments.
  • Follow-up tracker showing closure evidence and escalation of overdue actions.

Baseline documents in the kit

These free kit documents help you document or evidence clause 9.3. Each one is tailored to your organization when you build your kit.

Connect this work to your ISMS

Review the dependencies with 9.2 — Internal audit and 10.1 — Continual improvement. Keep the ownership and evidence consistent across these activities.

Plan your ISO/IEC 27001 implementation timeline for the wider implementation context.

Use the SIG and CAIQ questionnaire accelerator to find supporting documents. A mapping is a starting point: verify your actual operating evidence before answering a buyer.

For help adapting this to your environment, explore ISO/IEC 27001 consulting, starting with a free one-hour consultation.

Get these documents tailored to your organization

109 ready-to-edit documents, including all 19 mandatory ones, tailored from a short scoping questionnaire and linked to your risk register and SoA.

Start free

Plain-language interpretation by an ISO/IEC 27001 lead implementer, not the official text of ISO/IEC 27001:2022.