Clause 9 – Performance evaluation

Clause 9.2 Internal audit

Mandatory requirement Documented information required

What it means in plain language

Regularly check, through independent internal audits, whether the ISMS meets your own requirements and the standard and is working effectively. Plan an audit programme, use objective auditors, and report results to management.

Is it mandatory? Yes. Clauses 4–10 are the management-system requirements; all of them must be met to be certified, and none can be excluded.

Documented information

  • Audit programme(s) and audit results.

Why this requirement matters

Teams should build an audit programme that tests the ISMS against both ISO/IEC 27001 requirements and the organization’s own rules, using objective auditors and traceable scope. Make the reporting path clear, so findings are assigned to owners and followed through in the corrective action process rather than remaining isolated notes. A strong approach links each audit to risk, prior issues, and changes in operations.

Common auditor findings to check for

Potential gaps to test in your own environment, not a claim about observed audit frequency.

  • Audit scope omits an applicable clause or Annex A control, leaving no evidence that the omitted area was consciously risk-based or reviewed.
  • Auditor independence is weak because the same person designs, operates, and audits the process, reducing objectivity and the credibility of conclusions.
  • Audit reports list observations but do not trigger corrective actions, owners, or deadlines, so repeat weaknesses can persist without tracked closure.

How you can implement it

Tools and review intervals are examples; choose them according to risk, obligations and your operating environment.

  • Set an annual programme in the Audit Programme Register, then break it into a 1–3-year rolling cycle covering clauses, selected controls, and higher-risk processes. Assign each audit to an auditor who is independent of the activity being checked, with a review route for small teams where internal separation is limited.
  • Build each audit plan from the scope, previous findings, key risks, supplier dependencies, and recent changes. Include criteria, sample sizes, interview targets, and records to inspect, such as access requests, incident tickets, training logs, or backup test records, so the audit tests how work is actually performed.
  • Use a standard report template in the Internal Audit Procedure to capture criteria, evidence reviewed, nonconformities, opportunities for improvement, and severity or priority. Require each finding to be converted into a tracked corrective action with an owner, due date, and closure evidence reviewed by the audit lead.
  • After each cycle, trend recurring issues by process, clause, and control family, then feed those patterns into management review and the improvement register. Revisit audit frequency and depth where repeated failures, major changes, or supplier incidents show the audit programme is no longer proportionate to current risk.

What an auditor will ask to see

  • Approved audit programme showing cycle coverage, scope, and assigned auditors.
  • Signed audit plans and reports with sampled records, interview notes, and dated findings.
  • Independence declarations or role checks showing auditors did not audit their own work.
  • Corrective action records linked to audit findings, with closure evidence and verification notes.

Baseline documents in the kit

These free kit documents help you document or evidence clause 9.2. Each one is tailored to your organization when you build your kit.

Connect this work to your ISMS

Review the dependencies with 10.2 — Nonconformity and corrective action and 9.3 — Management review. Keep the ownership and evidence consistent across these activities.

Plan your ISO/IEC 27001 implementation timeline for the wider implementation context.

Use the SIG and CAIQ questionnaire accelerator to find supporting documents. A mapping is a starting point: verify your actual operating evidence before answering a buyer.

For help adapting this to your environment, explore ISO/IEC 27001 consulting, starting with a free one-hour consultation.

Get these documents tailored to your organization

109 ready-to-edit documents, including all 19 mandatory ones, tailored from a short scoping questionnaire and linked to your risk register and SoA.

Start free

Plain-language interpretation by an ISO/IEC 27001 lead implementer, not the official text of ISO/IEC 27001:2022.